06 November 2026 - 17:09

Legal gambling beyond the Treasury: the challenge of a new public sector policy

by Chiara Sambaldi and Andrea Strata

12 October 2026

The unsuccessful expiration of the government's mandate to reorganize physical gaming prompts some reflection, especially as a new phase begins, inevitably characterized by the extension of existing concessions.

The government appears to have underestimated the complexity of the issue and, above all, the difficulty of reconciling the differing positions and sensitivities, which have emerged forcefully even within the institutional decision-making sphere, into a shared synthesis.

The very complexity of the matter, which involves diverse and not always convergent interests, should have suggested a different approach, devoting more space to discussion on the regulatory model to be developed for an economically significant sector that, at the same time, is highly divisive in public debate.

Looking to the future of the sector, a change in approach would therefore be desirable. We need to start discussing a truly public gaming policy , moving beyond a vision in which decision-making on public gaming remains primarily at the mercy of the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF).

It is here, in fact, that one of the main contradictions of the system emerges.

On the one hand, write attorneys Chiara Sambaldi and Andrea Strata in the recent edition of PressGiochi MAG , our concession model limits private economic initiative and is justified, even at the European level, by the need to protect primary public interests, especially safety and health. The goal of increasing state revenue, however, cannot alone justify the restrictions imposed on operators.

On the other hand, jurisdiction over this matter continues to rest with the Ministry of Economy and Finance, which is naturally also called upon to pursue fiscal policy objectives. It is therefore not surprising that the 2027 policy document includes a focus on strengthening controls, including for revenue recovery, while making no explicit reference to the reorganization of land-based gaming.

The centrality of the treasury's interest also emerges, moreover, from administrative jurisprudence.

The Lazio Regional Administrative Court (TAR) recently ruled on the expiration of concession rights for horse racing and sports betting following the interruption of the activity (rulings no. 10649/2026 and no. 14446/2026).

In one of the cases examined, the concessionaire attributed the suspension of collection to the behavior of the store manager, who had terminated the contractual relationship. However, the judge deemed this circumstance irrelevant in the relationship with ADM: it is the concessionaire, as the holder of the concession and provider of a public service, that is responsible for ensuring the continuity of collection, even in the event of disputes with the manager.

The forfeiture is therefore based on the protection of the public interest in the continuity of service and, with it, the taxpayer's interest in the proceeds from gaming and betting. In this regard, the contractual issues within the sales network remain in the background.

The TAR has thus accepted the position already expressed by the Council of State, according to which " the principle that governs the performance of the betting collection activity is the achievement of the interests of the treasury ", recognizing that the latter prevail over the economic interest of the concessionaire in maintaining the structure of its sales network (Council of State, section VII, no. 10414/2023).

The same rulings also reiterate that, in the presence of the conditions set out in the agreement, forfeiture constitutes a binding power for ADM and not a discretionary choice.

If we broaden our gaze beyond individual decisions, however, a more general question emerges.

Over the years, administrative jurisprudence has assumed an increasingly important role in concretely defining the sector's balance, partly due to the legislator's prolonged difficulty in achieving a comprehensive reorganization of the physical network. Judges are thus required to apply existing rules and conventions and resolve individual conflicts, but they cannot replace policy in the construction of a comprehensive model.

And that's probably the key point.

Health, safety, and public order, consumer and vulnerable population protection, combating illegal gambling, the economic sustainability of the legal network, and safeguarding tax revenues cannot be addressed as separate objectives. They require a political synthesis capable of striking a balance between diverse and, at times, conflicting interests.

Adopting a public gaming policy means taking responsibility for building a socially and economically sustainable model, recognizing that every choice has consequences for the legal network, consumers, local communities, state revenues, and the ability to combat illegal gambling.

This requires discussion, listening, and mediation, but above all, a clear and stable regulatory framework capable of offering guarantees to users and clear conditions to operators required to invest within the concession system.

A governing policy for the sector cannot, therefore, be based exclusively, or predominantly, on fiscal considerations. Regulatory decisions should be developed through effective coordination between the administrations responsible for protecting the various public interests involved. Likewise, relationships between the State, Regions, and local authorities should foster genuine, loyal institutional collaboration , thus overcoming the "dialogue of the deaf" that has, for too long, plagued discussions on public gaming.

Public policy , according to David Easton's well-known definition, is the process through which institutions allocate values ​​within society. This definition remains relevant today precisely because it emphasizes the responsibility of politicians to make choices, strike balances, and define priorities when differing collective interests are at stake.

This is exactly what the gaming industry needs today.

The failure to implement the delegation on physical gaming could, therefore, be transformed into an opportunity to start again not from yet another draft regulation, but from the preliminary identification of the objectives the State intends to pursue, the tools to achieve them, and the balance to be struck between health protection, safety, legality, network sustainability, and fiscal interests.

Only starting from this fundamental choice will it be possible to speak, in the true sense, of reorganization. Otherwise, the risk is that of continuing to govern a complex sector through extensions, piecemeal interventions, and judicial decisions, once again postponing the synthesis of disparate interests that, by its very nature, can only be achieved by politics.

PressGames

Image source: https://depositphotos.com/